Skip to main content

William Turnbull / MLTW Collection

 Collection
Identifier: 2000--9

Scope and Contents

The records of the William Turnbull Jr./MLTW collection span the years 1952-1997. The collection is organized into eight series: Personal Papers, Professional Papers, Faculty Records, Office Records, Project Records, Major Projects, Artifacts, and Additional Donations. Within these series, original order has been maintained wherever evident. Where an original order was not evident, records have been arranged either chronologically or alphabetically as noted in the Series Description.

The majority of the collection documents William Turnbull Jr./MLTW projects between 1958-1997. The small amounts of Personal Papers consist of documentation related to Turnbull’s Army service, student work including his Master’s thesis at Princeton, personal financial records, and correspondence. The Professional Papers series contains extensive coverage of Turnbull’s involvement in various local and professional associations, including the Community Appearances Advisory Board in Sausalito (where he lived for most of his adult life), the American Institute of Architects, his fellowship at the American Academy in Rome, and his involvement in the Sea Ranch Design Committee. This series also documents the numerous awards that the firm received, as well as the lectures given by Turnbull across the globe and the juries on which he served in order to honor other members of his profession.

The Faculty Papers are a record of the time Turnbull spent teaching at various institutions around the country, including significant appointments at the architecture schools of UC Berkeley and Yale (during Charles Moore’s tenure as chair and dean). Most of the papers in this series are course materials: syllabi, reading lists, and lecture notes. Office Records primarily document the public relations efforts of the firm through brochures, photographs, correspondence, and (when the efforts were successful) tearsheets from publications in which the projects were featured. This series also contains the partnership and dissolution documents from each of the firms in which both Charles Moore and Turnbull were partners. The correspondence in this series is evidence of the close relationships that evolved between Turnbull’s firm and the vendors it worked with closely to achieve its vision, including photographer Morley Baer and the principals of the Finnish textile design firm Marimekko Oy. This series also includes documentation of the various exhibitions at museums and galleries in which the work of the firm was displayed.

While the office records document the firm’s official correspondence, most of the correspondence that brings the work of Turnbull’s firm to life is located in the Project Records series. Along with construction photographs, meeting and telephone notes, “napkin sketches” and other quick drawings, and financial records, the project records are a rich source of correspondence between the architects and their clients, contractors, vendors, and (in some instances) lawyers. Occasional clippings may also be found among the records. Through this series one comes to know the other major partners and associates in the firm, including Robert Simpson, Gerd Althofer, Richard Garlinghouse, Karl G. Smith II, Hildegard (Heidi) Richardson, and Turnbull’s sister, Margaret Turnbull Simon (who, with Wendy Libby, ran the firm’s interior design division). Later principals, including Mary Griffin and Eric Haesloop, appear in the series after 1980. The correspondence documents Turnbull’s relationships with other architects and design professionals, including the landscape architects Lawrence Halprin and Mae and David Arbegast; Turnbull’s former partners and their successor firms including Charles Moore’s Urban Innovations Group and Moore Ruble Yudell; and Donlyn Lyndon’s later firm of Lyndon/Buchanan. It is also not an overstatement to call “collaborators” Turnbull’s main Northern California contractor Matt Sylvia (who constructed most of the buildings at Sea Ranch and in Napa and Sonoma Counties), renderer Bill Hersey, photographers Morley Baer and Roger Sturtevant, and structural engineers Peter Culley, Steven Tipping, Fook Z. Lee, and the firm of Rutherford & Chekene. Much correspondence with them is represented in these records.

The projects themselves are all the richer for their clients, who were, almost to a person, warm, intelligent, opinionated people who came to Turnbull not because he was a “name architect,” but because his vision of lightly but intentionally inhabiting a space and the surrounding landscape rang true to their own. Most of Turnbull’s residential architecture is worthy of mention here, but of particular note – those projects where, in the process, the clients became close friends – are the houses commissioned by the Hoopers, the Swifts, the Phelans (in association with Richard Whitaker, Turnbull’s former partner), the Zimmermans, Gerald Hines, the DiGiorgios, the Allewelts, the Davidows, the Fishers, the Witherspoons, the Cakebreads, the Sandlers, the Budges, the Tatums, the Spencers, and above all, Reverdy and Marta Johnson, who later became Turnbull’s partners in the Johnson/Turnbull Winery.

Turnbull’s larger projects for corporate or governmental entities display much of the same reverence for both space and surroundings that his residential architecture does, but on a larger scale. The Sea Ranch development, commissioned by Oceanic Properties, is the development that put Turnbull on the architectural map, as well as influenced the look of developments on the Pacific coastline for decades to come. After Sea Ranch, one of Turnbull’s earliest corporate clients was Golden West Savings and Loan (later World Savings), owned and operated by Herbert and Marion Sandler. Turnbull’s firm created a signature design for each of the branches in northern California, and later served as a design advisor to the savings and loan when it began to build in other states across the country. Some other commissions of note – there are many more than those on this list – include Conifer Housing in Tacoma, Washington, several prototype houses for Weyerhauser, Kresge College at the University of California, Santa Cruz, the Design|Research Store at Embarcadero Center, San Francisco, Beaver Creek condominiums in Vail, Colorado and Woodrun Place in Snowmass, Colorado, the Biloxi Library and Cultural Center in Mississippi, the Embarcadero Promenade in San Francisco, Cakebread Cellars in the Napa Valley (among many wineries in the area), the American Club in Hong Kong, Mountain View Civic Center in California, and residence halls at Arizona State University. Turnbull’s larger projects also include a number of unbuilt projects wherein he served as an advisor for large nonprofits or governmental entities seeking expert land-use planning advice. Among his clients were the Oregon State Coastal Commission, the California Coastal Conservancy, the State of California Attorney General’s Office, and the Nature Conservancy.

Also of note in the Project Records are those projects that were either entirely the work of Charles Moore or were instigated by Moore. Many Moore projects in this series do not have job numbers, but are listed with Moore as a “contributor.” Other Turnbull projects in which Moore played a major design role were the Hines residence, the Louisiana World Exposition, the Faculty Club at the University of California, Santa Barbara, several early residences, and the Sea Ranch Condominium #1.

The Major Projects series consists of only one project: Foothill Housing at the University of California, Berkeley. The project consists of three elements: Hillside Housing and Commons, La Loma Housing, and a parking lot. William Turnbull Associates was the associate architect for this project, partnered with Ratcliff Architects as the executive architect. Due to time constraints, the records in this series were processed and inventoried, but not appraised.

The two other series in the collection are Artifacts, which consists of eleven models of various Turnbull projects, and Additional Donations, which consist of Turnbull’s student work and some early personal papers.

All series in this collection have been appraised and processed, except the Foothill Housing in Major Projects, which was processed and inventoried, but not appraised. The Project Records have been processed and appraised through the year 1986; from 1987 on, the records were processed and inventoried, but appraised. Certain project records absent from the collection may have been retained by the successor firm, Turnbull Griffin Haesloop, in order to complete projects begun while Turnbull was alive.

Dates

  • Creation: Majority of material found within 1959-1997

Creator

Conditions Governing Access

Collection is open for research.

Conditions Governing Use

All requests for permission to publish, reproduce, or quote from materials in the collection should be discussed with the Curator.

Biographical / Historical

William Turnbull, Jr. was born in New York on April 1, 1935 and raised on a farm in Far Hills, New Jersey. Both his father and grandfather were architects: the latter, George B. Post, was the architect of the New York Stock Exchange and planner of Forest Hills Gardens, and in 1911 won the gold medal from the American Institute of Architects. As was his “birthright,” Turnbull studied architecture at Princeton and the Ecole des Beaux Arts in Paris. He returned to Princeton to receive his Master’s degree in 1959, studying under Louis I. Kahn and producing a thesis on the redevelopment of Ellis Island. For this thesis, he received the AIA Student Medal. He befriended Charles Moore, a fellow graduate student at Princeton, and in 1960 moved to San Francisco, where he began working at Skidmore, Owings and Merrill. One of his achievements at SOM was as a designer of the Big Sur Coast Master Plan, which has been written into law and protects nearly 100 miles of pristine California coastline from development.

In 1963, at the age of 27, Turnbull co-founded the firm of MLTW with fellow principals Charles Moore, Donlyn Lyndon, and Richard Whitaker. In a 1968 letter to architectural historian David Gebhardt, Turnbull wrote of the MLTW collaboration, “Essentially Chuck, Don, Dick and I are or were all designers. We worked together with the man having the strongest opinion about a subject usually prevailing. This built-in system of checks and balances was one of the reasons why the quality of design was so high. On each project, identification with the solution varied, but all were involved…. We have thought of ourselves as a group of designers and talk about ourselves that way: the work being the product of a dialogue.” The four designers in MLTW, along with the landscape architect Lawrence Halprin, together designed the master plan for the Sea Ranch, located on the Sonoma coast in northern California, as well as the first structure on the site, Condominium #1. The condominium drew high praise from critics and the general public alike, and the firm instantly made a name for itself. Sea Ranch continued to grow and evolve throughout Turnbull’s life, and he remained constantly involved with it: serving on the design committee; designing two athletic centers, a corporation yard, and employee housing; creating house after house (including 17 versions of his “Spec House II” or “Binker Barn”) for clients almost to the time of his death.

In addition to Sea Ranch, MLTW completed several other significant projects, including Kresge College at the University of California, Santa Cruz and the Faculty Club at UC-Santa Barbara. During this time, Turnbull also taught several architecture and landscape architecture studios at UC-Berkeley. He co-authored (with Charles Moore) and produced drawings for the 1971 publication The Place of Houses. In 1967, he married Wendy Woods, from whom he was later divorced.

By 1970, all three of the other principals of MLTW had left the firm to pursue academic careers and begin new firms. Turnbull remained in San Francisco and renamed his practice William Turnbull Associates, located at Pier 1 1/2 on San Francisco’s Embarcadero. He continued to collaborate with Charles Moore on many projects, but also began to make a name for himself as a designer, accepting important commissions from Golden West Savings & Loan, Warren and Teeny Zimmerman, Sandy and Barbara Tatum (whose house won the coveted “Record House of the Year” award in 1972 from Architectural Record) and a low-income housing development in Tacoma, Washington called Conifer.

In the early 1970s, Turnbull and his friend (and lawyer, and client) Reverdy Johnson went into business together growing grapes in an esteemed region of the Napa Valley. When, one year, the winery to which they usually supplied their grapes declined to purchase them, Turnbull and Johnson invested in winemaking equipment and began (with the expert assistance of oenologist Kristin Belair) to produce their own award-winning Cabernet Sauvignon and Chardonnay throughout the 1970s and 1980s under the name Johnson Turnbull Vineyards. Turnbull designed all of the facilities for the winery, as well as for their neighbors, fellow winemakers Jack and Dolores Cakebread. Johnson and Turnbull remained active in the Napa Valley winemaking community until the vineyards were sold in the mid-1980s.

Turnbull was elected a Fellow of the American Institute of Architects in 1976, and attended the American Academy in Rome in 1980. He was a sought-after speaker due to his quiet rejection of architectural fads such as Postmodernism and Deconstructionism, and lectured at architecture schools throughout the U.S.. At ease with projects of any scale, he continued to design modest, regionally-inspired houses while at the same time taking on enormous international projects such as the American Club in Hong Kong.

In 1985, Turnbull married architect Mary Griffin, who became a partner in his firm. Through the 1980s and ‘90s, William Turnbull Associates thrived as their work became notable for its consistency of vision in an environment of wildly divergent architectural styles. William Turnbull Associates won the California Council of the American Institute of Architects “Firm of the Year” award in 1986, and the same award from the AIA in 1995. Near the end of his life, Turnbull observed, “The older I get, the more I think that architecture should be like mashed potatoes and not like ice-cream sundaes.” Turnbull died of prostate cancer on June 26, 1997 at the age of 62. His wife and his partner Eric Haesloop continue the practice, under the name Turnbull Griffin Haesloop, in San Francisco, California.

Firm History:

1962-1965 MLTW 1966-1970 MLTW Moore Turnbull 1970-1997 William Turnbull Associates (with a brief interlude of simply “Turnbull Associates”) 1997-present Turnbull Griffin Haesloop

Sources:

Filler, Martin. “Vernacular virtuoso” [Turnbull obituary]. House Beautiful, v. 139 no. 10 (October 1997), 114-116.

Ketchum, Diana. “Master builder” [Turnbull obituary]. San Francisco Examiner, July 6, 1997.

Temko, Allan. “William Turnbull Jr.” [Turnbull obituary]. San Francisco Chronicle, June 30, 1997.

Stout, William and Dung Ngo, eds. William Turnbull, Jr.: Buildings in the Landscape. San Francisco: William Stout Publishers, 2000. Typed letter from William Turnbull to David Gebhardt, 1968.

Extent

900 Linear Feet: (96 cartons, 14 boxes, 2 flat boxes, 13 linear feet mounted and framed material, approximately 700 tubes, 11 artifacts)

Language of Materials

English

Processing Information

The William Turnbull, Jr./MLTW collection was processed in 2004 by Betsy Frederick-Rothwell, an assistant archivist with an M.Arch and extensive experience in processing other Modern architecture collections at the EDA, and Laura Tatum, project archivist with an MSI from the University of Michigan. Together, we processed and arranged this collection according to the guidelines published in the Standard Series for Architecture and Landscape Design Records: A Tool for the Arrangement and Description of Archival Collections by Kelcy Shepherd and Waverly Lowell.

The Turnbull collection was donated to the Environmental Design Archives in 2000 by Mary Griffin Turnbull, Turnbull’s widow and former partner in the firm Turnbull & Associates. At the time of the donation, the collection was housed in the firm’s main office at Pier 1 1/2, on the Embarcadero in San Francisco. The damp, dank conditions of the storage warehouse made appraisal and processing of this extremely large collection more time-consuming than usual. In the interests of long-term preservation, the majority of metal fasteners – most of which had already rusted – were removed, and great care was taken to separate more corrosive types of paper from other, more stable media.

The archivists coordinating the transfer of materials to the Environmental Design Archives, Kelcy Shepherd and Waverly Lowell, made the immediate appraisal decision to acquire only those projects that appeared to include original drawings in the records. This cut the number of records that the EDA eventually accessioned by about one-third. Additionally, the successor firm of Turnbull Griffin Haesloop, located in Berkeley, CA, retained some of the later records for their own office use. Thus, while the collection at the EDA is vast and all major projects are well-represented, the collection cannot be called comprehensive.

When appraising this collection, Betsy and I adhered to the same standards that we had set while appraising the Wurster collection. Our goal was to remove as much non-permanent material as possible as quickly as possible while maintaining high archival standards. We discovered, as we learned more about the projects, certain eccentricities and design philosophies that Turnbull and the members of his firm held dear. Because of this, we retained some items that might otherwise have been removed, such as paint samples and fabric swatches (especially fabric designed by Marimekko). These items may give the researcher a more tangible sense of the exuberance that the firm embraced, particularly in the 1960s-early 1970s. We retained most telephone notes, especially as that became the primary means of communication between the firm and its clients and contractors. It is also interesting to “witness” the rise of the computer and the fax machine in architectural practice through a case study of this firm’s records – from its introduction in the late 1970s through its widespread use in the 1990s.

Despite these technological advances, Turnbull remained true to his passion – drafting by hand. The project records are sprinkled liberally with “napkin sketches” and other quick drawings where he worked his ideas through on paper, often being very self-critical (“possible” and “not this one” are written next to many of these “first tries”). The schematic and design development drawings are also mostly in his hand and predominantly on yellow tracing paper. Thousands of these small drawings exist. Betsy’s architecturally-trained eye separated the wheat from the chaff, and the drawings that remain in the collection now are those with permanent research value.

The project records came to us arranged, for the most part, chronologically and in job-number order. Those projects without job numbers were arranged chronologically at the end of the numbered projects. Large projects often came to us divided into many folders, the most standard of which were Correspondence, Meeting and Telephone Notes, Miscellaneous Notes and Sketches, Financial, and Field Reports. When, after appraisal, a project’s records remained voluminous enough to warrant separate foldering, these (and other, more specific) folder titles were retained. For smaller projects, all records were placed into a single folder with the client’s name, the location of the project, and the job number as identifiers. The collection has been heavily appraised, with approximately one out of every three cartons removed as non-permanent material. The non-permanent material consisted primarily of duplicates, transmittal letters, routine correspondence and submittals, product literature and samples, unsuccessful bids, and copies of codes and regulations readily available elsewhere.

-- Laura Tatum, December 2004

Additional material was donated by Griffin after the death of Turnbull’s mother, Elizabeth, in 2004. On a part-time basis between 2009 and 2011, Betsy Frederick-Rothwell processed the Additional Donation of student work and early personal papers, processed and roughly arranged the Major Projects, and re-housed some materials for more efficient storage. The finding aid, project index, and file list were also updated and confirmed at this time.

-- Betsy Frederick-Rothwell, June 2011

Title
William Turnbull, Jr. / MLTW Collection
Status
Completed
Author
Betsy Frederick-Rothwell and Laura Tatum
Date
2004, 2011
Description rules
Describing Archives: A Content Standard
Language of description
English
Script of description
Latin
Sponsor
Arrangement and description of this collection was funded by a grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities

Repository Details

Part of the University of California, Berkeley. College of Environmental Design. Environmental Design Archives Repository

Contact:
230 Bauer Wurster Hall #1820
Berkeley CA 94720-1820 USA